I am a native of Manali and lived there all my life. I love my place and I'm very touchy about the environmental issue, but I'm also practical man. Although in principal I don't like this heli-skiing business for various reasons, but when it comes to it helping the economy of the local people I have don't mind it. But the problem with this is that, the place belongs to us local people and but all the benefits are taken by the outsiders, e.g the business run by an Australian, the hotel they hire is owned by some one from Delhi, the pilots are European and the customers are all Europeans. So how does it help the local people, may be doing some mean job like driving, helping as porters, all of which is very poorly paid, maybe Euro 50 per month to keep it on higher side. I forgot another thing, the owner of the agency to keep his selfish interest going has been making false promise to so many young skiers from the valley, that he would employ them. Yes! he has employed couple of them and one of the guys happens to be very good friend of mine. But the truth of the matter is that what the owner does is uses these guys, he hires them at 5 Euros a day, and gets them to do the most dangerous job of leading the pack while skiing down the dangerous terrain. Worst thing is that he does not even insure them, and these guys are not hired full whole year but part time. Imagine if the owner has to hire some one from Europe he would have to shell may be thousand of times more only for his insurance leave the service. I think its disgusting, I suggest all you heli- skiing lovers please come to my place and enjoy but at least give what is due to these guys who put their life for your entertainment. I would also like to mention that couple of years back the owner of the firm promised these guides that he would sponsor their learning of higher skills in Europe but it has never happened. Rest I leave all for your judgment.
Tsering
Step taken against the heli-ski was really appreciable. Nearby people used to say it was less the ski more animal poaching and smuggling. Also disturbing the wildlife like brown bear.
oo aa, helicopter very bad haha, maybe you want all the forests to be cut out, pistes dug all over the mountain, lifts and gondolas all over it and it will be perfect. Then you will miss the only helicopter. Ooh heli-skiing is such an environmental concern.
I was pleased to see a number of comments from individuals expressing concern about the invasive nature of heli-skiing. It seems there are more people up here who are against it than for it. Interestingly, up until today, we have had very small snowfall here, which has meant a peaceful time for the residents in Kullu Valley as no heli-skiing chopper has been buzzing around. Yes, I also witnessed the chopper flying very low over Manali town last year doing sightseeing............. I don't know if the rumours are true, but I heard some of the trips they had been doing were for hunting wildlife. This is totally illegal and a disgrace. Let's hope, with the new information we now have on climate change and the focus on environmental concerns, the heli skiing will stop. Not just here, but globally. It's about time humans remembered they are a part of nature and not apart from it!
January 06, 2007
John Houghton
from
United Kingdom
Hi Mat
Good point, ok i'll walk then... and i'll only eat potatoes and not stay in any hotels or thumb a lift... might not be there till next winter though!
November 26, 2006
Matthew Harvey
from
United Kingdom
Dear John Houghton...
Please explain to me how you are a "true environmentalist" and yet you're gunna fly half way around the world just to go skiing?
The local people of Manali clearly have a problem with the noise. It would be disrespectful for heli-skiing companies not to consult local people about their concerns.
Good luck to all people who are fighting against Manali Heli-Ski...The Himalayas are a place to ski, but not without the consent of local people.
September 06, 2006
John Houghton
from
United Kingdom
Myself and a group of seven are really looking forward to visiting Gulmarg this winter and also thinking of heli-skiing in Himachal... clearly there is a problem with the heli ski operation here, and by heli-skiing in Himachal with all the strong local dislike of the operation I would think again before coming. Surely there may be some sort of compromise, like we do here in the Alps. Restricted flying times, certain areas off limits (especially populated areas) etc.. I would of thought that tourism is something to be encouraged...?
I am a Ski/board fanatic but also a true enviromentlist and I would always truly respect the wishes and customs of people to which ever counrty I visit to practice my passion in life......
Dear Resident's of Valley of Gods,
I wish to humbly apologize for the transgressions made against your land. I whole heartedly agree with each and every one of you who has a problem with this heli-skiing. To me the Himalayan’s are a beautiful, mysterious, and wonderful place (one that some day I would hope to visit). It brings me great sadness to see such rude behavior from fellow skiers/snowboarders. Recently I read an article, http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1357016/posts . Will this also be affecting you? I am interested in skiing and working to build equal sustainable economies with beneficial and productive outcomes, but do not want to put energy into something negative.
Please know that there are people out there like me who love the snow, but also love the environment and respect the people who live there. I hope that anyone who reads this site will not go to Manali as long as such disruptive and non-constructive things are happening.
Amitabha;
Eli
I also live up here in the Valley of Gods and whole heartedly agree with the other writers. The heliskiing is making life miserable for all people and animals living here. Thankfully the season is now over for this year, but the helicopters are now doing sightseeing tours around the Manali area, so it's still a nightmare.
Us residents will be doing everything we can to make sure this disturbance is brought to an end and the delicate eco balance of this area is given a chance to recover. If you want to heli ski, you obviously have money to burn. Go and build an artificial slope near where you live and see how much you enjoy the constant racket of helicopters flying overhead.
This comment by Mr Lancaster shows he does not care about local people and the culture the helicopters are disturbing. Early morning is a time for pooga's and worship at the temples in this Valley of the Gods. It's also a time for yoga and meditation, not just for foreign tourists, but for locals as well.
It is a disgrace that these helicopters are allowed to fly directly from a holiday resort and not an authorised airport. I have seen the helicopters flying in very bad weather and on one occasion I heard one flying after sunset. This caused great distress to locals who were frightened and thought it was the Army.